Alex DeBrincat Future With Senators Remains in Limbo

Ever since DeBrincat was acquired, questions lingered if he really wanted to be in Ottawa. Because the team gave up so much to acquire him, the hope for them was that they could lock up the 25-year-old for years to come, but that never came to fruition. Reports swirled immediately that he was unwilling to negotiate a contract extension after being acquired and wanted to wait and see how the season played out. It was a sentiment he held all season long whenever he was asked about potentially signing a contract extension.

On April 10, Sens’ general manager Pierre Dorion told the media that they would qualify DeBrincat, even if they don’t agree to a long-term deal. According to CapFriendly, his qualifying offer is one-year, $9 million. DeBrincat mentioned during his exit interviews that he is open to staying in Ottawa long-term but wants time to talk things through with his agent and family, which is a perfectly reasonable stance. However, after the interview was released, a TSN report surfaced with comments from Bruce Garrioch of Postmedia, that everything he has heard indicates DeBrincat has no inclination of signing. He said the team could trade him at the NHL Draft in June if they cannot reach a long-term agreement.

These are very conflicting reports from a general manager stating he intends to re-sign the forward, regardless of a long-term agreement, to then hear that that is possibly not the case. However, vague statements, like DeBrincat made during his press conference, are common. For example, it was reported last summer that Pittsburgh Penguins forward Evgeni Malkin felt disrespected during contract extension talks, and it made it sound like he would ultimately sign elsewhere. However, he eventually agreed to a four-year, $24.4 million extension. Therefore, no one will know which way DeBrincat is truly leaning until a signing is made official.

DeBrincat can choose to decline his qualifying offer, and he would remain a restricted free agent (RFA). There is also the possibility that he could receive an offer sheet from another team, but the Sens could match it. The last time an offer sheet was made in NHL was back in 2021 (Jesperi Kotkaniemi), but it is possible for a player like DeBrincat.

Overall, it would hurt for the Senators to lose DeBrincat. He spent most of the season on the second line with Shane Pinto and Drake Batherson where they generated the second-most goals-for (15) and chances-for (468). Pinto is also an RFA this summer, so keeping that line together next season looks to be the priority. Garnering that with Brady Tkachuk, Claude Giroux, Tim Stützle, and newcomer Jakob Chychrun would continue to set the tone for the future. But unfortunately for Sens’ fans, there is little to go on with how this saga may end. Dorion knew it was risky to acquire a player that would not commit to signing, but they’re hoping the greater the risk, the greater the reward.